by Rhoda Wilson, Expose News:
On Wednesday, the European Court of Justice ruled that the European Commission was wrong to conceal details of its multi-billion euro deals for covid vaccines.
Ursula von der Leyen was already under scrutiny for allegedly keeping secret and deleting text messages with Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla over vaccine purchases in a controversy dubbed “Deletegate.” Wednesday’s court ruling is separate to that case.
Apart from the obvious negative impact this is likely to have on von der Leyen’s bid for a second term as the President of the European Commission, the Court also stated that Pfizer is liable for damages if its covid vaccine is defective.
TRUTH LIVES on at https://sgtreport.tv/
In October 2021, Green MEPs requested access to the covid vaccine contracts negotiated by the European Commission so that the terms and conditions of the agreements could be known.
According to the group, the decision to take the case to the High Court came after months of correspondence with the European Commission asking for transparent access to the contracts, to which the executive only provided heavily redacted versions.
Yesterday the European Court of Justice ruled that the Commission did not give sufficient access to the purchase agreements and considers that the executive’s decision to publish only redacted versions of the contracts contains irregularities.
As Politico reported:
Ursula von der Leyen’s bid for a second term as European Commission chief has been dealt a major blow after a top EU court ruled she was not transparent enough with the public about covid-19 vaccine contracts.
The General Court of the European Union ruled against the Commission’s decision to redact large parts of the contracts before making them available.
The General Court on Wednesday partially upheld the MEPs’ lawsuit and annulled the Commission’s decision to redact parts of the contracts.
It pushed against the Commission’s decision to conceal provisions on indemnification, arguing that the Commission failed to prove how those clauses would undermine the commercial interests of the pharmaceutical companies.
“The new European Commission must now adapt their handling of access to documents requests to be in line with today’s ruling,” [Tilly Metz, one of the Green MEPs who filed the lawsuit, said].
The Commission can appeal the ruling within two months and 10 days of the decision.
Von der Leyen loses court case in blow to her 2nd-term bid, Politico, 17 July 2024
Politico noted that other cases regarding the Pfizer contracts and communication between von der Leyen and Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla are also pending in different EU jurisdictions.
In 2023, a Belgian lobbyist, Frédéric Baldan, filed a complaint against von der Leyen personally, alleging that she and Bourla directly negotiated a €1.8 billion contract extension via text messages, undermining public trust and Belgium’s public finances. The Belgian authorities initiated the case in early 2023. Subsequently, the governments of Hungary and Poland joined the lawsuit.
In April 2024, Spot Media reported that the European Public Prosecutor’s Office (“EPPO”) – the EU’s anti-corruption agency – had in recent months taken over the Belgian prosecutors’ investigation into von der Leyen for “interference in public functions, deletion of text messages, corruption and conflict of interest.”
Before expanding to include specific concerns over the handling of vaccine orders by von der Leyen, the EEPO had already launched an investigation into the acquisition of covid vaccines across the European Union. The probe was confirmed in October 2022, amid “extremely high” public interest.
In May 2023, EPPO head Laura Codruța Kövesi hinted that the investigation had been expanded to involve activities relevant to the United States, potentially indicating a transatlantic angle to the inquiry.
Von der Leyen is no stranger to controversy surrounding the awarding of contracts. In 2020, she faced criticism over contracting practices during her tenure as Germany’s Defence Minister. She was accused of her department awarding lucrative contracts from the Defence Ministry to outside consultants without proper oversight.
A parliamentary committee report cleared her of direct responsibility, attributing mistakes to officials below her level. However, von der Leyen acknowledged “mistakes have been made” and expressed regret over the lack of oversight.
German Green Party MP Tobias Lindner said at the time that the government committee had done an “ultimately very simple” assessment of the findings. “A former state secretary and a retired general are being named as the sole responsible parties for the consultancy affair, so that an EU Commission president can act in Brussels with as few scratches as possible,” he said.
